Anonymous

When psychologists say that a given trait is due more to nature than nurture they mean what?

3

3 Answers

Jenny Garden Profile
Jenny Garden , MA (First Class) Psychology; MSc Health Psychology., answered

The nature vs nurture debate in psychology is concerned with the extent to which behaviours, traits and personality are inherited (ie genetic) or acquired (ie learned). Accordingly, when psychologists say that a given trait is due more to nature than nurture, they mean that the particular trait is more a product of genes than social or environmental factors.

It has long been accepted that certain physical characteristics are determined by genes (for example, eye colour, skin pigmentation and certain diseases), and that other characteristics are strongly influenced by genes (for example, height, weight, and vulnerability to specific diseases). This has led to speculation that psychological characteristics may also be genetically determined or influenced. It is a topic which has been much debated, with the stance taken by psychologists varying greatly. The diagram below gives a good summary of the different approaches.

In recent years, many psychologists have recognised that both nature and nurture play an important role in the development of traits and personality. Accordingly, some modern psychologists now consider the nature vs nurture question naive and outdated. The psychologist Donald Hebb famously once responded to a journalist's question of "which, nature or nurture, contributes more to personality?" by asking, "which contributes more to the area of a rectangle, its length or its width?"






John McCann Profile
John McCann answered

They mean nothing as behavioral traits are measured by the VARIANCE from the mean of the traits as distributed. In other words difference, not similarity, is measured

No one can say for sure how much nature or nurture contributes to human behavioral traits.

What one can say for sure is that behavioral traits are the result of nature via nurture.

El Lly Profile
El Lly answered

Nature and nurture are two very separate, very distinct terms in human psychology. They describe the aetiology behind different psychological factors, including disorders/problems and just our general state of being.

The term nature denotes the things we are born with. This means it is embedded in our genetics/DNA and are not related to our environment or social conditioning. This includes many mental illnesses which are hereditary and due to neurological differences.

The term nurture describes what we are taught. This includes how we are raised, our social experiences, environmental conditioning and the like. In essence, these are the external variables, where as nature relates to internal variables.

Things that pertain to 'nature' can not be altered or controlled without medical interference. They are just what we are born with. The latter (nurture) can also be very difficult to amend but it is possible to achieve through cognitive behavioural therapy if necessary.

I hope this helps.


Answer Question

Anonymous